Butler Beach, FL Flood Map
BestNeighborhood estimates that 53% of residents in Butler Beach, about half, live in a FEMA high-risk flood zone, compared with 24% in Florida and 5.6% nationwide.
These figures come from BestNeighborhood's flood model. Where FEMA has studied the ground, the model uses FEMA's own zones; where FEMA's maps leave gaps, it estimates the zone from what FEMA drew on similar ground nearby.
This page is for people who live in Butler Beach, or are thinking of moving there, and are concerned about large-scale flooding. It maps flood zones street by street and shows the 30-year chance of a flood and flood claims paid since 1982.
What this map counts as a flood
This map counts floods from rivers and creeks that leave their banks; in Butler Beach, residents of the high-risk zone live along waterways such as the Matanzas River and Atlantic Ocean. Along the coast it also counts the sea pushed ashore by storms, the flooding FEMA maps in the coastal zones of Butler Beach.
On FEMA's scale, the high-risk zone is the 1%-a-year zone, also called the 100-year floodplain, and about 2,800 residents of Butler Beach live in it. The moderate zone, where the chance is 0.2% to 1% a year, is home to about 1,100 more.
In Butler Beach, these figures follow FEMA's own flood zones wherever its digital map covers the ground.
Rain that floods streets and basements in Butler Beach away from a waterway is outside this map. Of the paid flood claims in Butler Beach, 2.9% came from buildings outside the high-risk zone, against 25% across the U.S.
How likely is a flood in Butler Beach?
In FEMA's high-risk zone in Butler Beach, a flood has a 1% or greater chance each year, or at least 1 in 4 over a 30-year mortgage. In the moderate zone of Butler Beach, the chance is 0.2% to 1% a year, from about 1 in 17 to 1 in 4 over 30 years.
| Flood zone | Chance in a year | Chance over 30 years | Butler Beach residents | Florida residents | U.S. residents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| High risk: Zones AE and VE | 1% or more | about 1 in 4 or more | 53% | 24% | 5.6% |
| Moderate risk: Zone X (shaded) | 0.2% to 1% | about 1 in 17 to 1 in 4 | 20% | 5.3% | 4.5% |
| Minimal risk: Zone X | under 0.2% | under 1 in 17 | 27% | 65% | 83% |
What flooding looks like in Butler Beach
Butler Beach ranks 61st of the 511 cities in Florida with 5,000 or more residents and flood maps for the share of residents in FEMA's high-risk flood zone, at 53%. Payouts run high as well: a typical paid claim in Butler Beach is about $26,000, while the U.S. median is $13,000. Along the Matanzas River alone, about 1,700 residents live in the high-risk zone.
What stands out
- A Category 1 hurricane's storm surge could reach 53% of residents in Butler Beach, about half, by the National Hurricane Center's maps.
- 61% of the residents in Butler Beach's high-risk zone, about 1,700 people, live along the Matanzas River alone.
- Hurricane Matthew in 2016 alone produced 62% of the paid flood claims in Butler Beach since 1982.
Waterways in Butler Beach's flood zones
Of the waterways in Butler Beach, the Matanzas River has the most residents in the high-risk zone along it, about 1,700 or 61% of the total. Next are Atlantic Ocean, with about 620, and San Julian Creek, with about 490.
| Waterway | Residents in the high-risk zone along it |
|---|---|
| Matanzas River | 1,700 |
| Atlantic Ocean | 620 |
| San Julian Creek | 490 |
Flood history: what insurance claims show
Since 1982, federal flood insurance has paid about 970 claims in Butler Beach, $42 million in all. These claims count only buildings insured by the National Flood Insurance Program, so uninsured flood damage in Butler Beach is not in them.
- 1982 to 1989: no paid claims
- 1990: 1 paid claim, $630 paid
- 1991: no paid claims
- 1992: 1 paid claim, $540 paid
- 1993: no paid claims
- 1994: 3 paid claims, $4,900 paid
- 1995: 2 paid claims, $5,800 paid
- 1996: 1 paid claim, $160 paid
- 1997 to 1998: no paid claims
- 1999: 25 paid claims, $220,000 paid
- 2000: no paid claims
- 2001: 18 paid claims, $100,000 paid
- 2002: 1 paid claim, $26,000 paid
- 2003: no paid claims
- 2004: 4 paid claims, $16,000 paid
- 2005 to 2007: no paid claims
- 2008: 1 paid claim, $12,000 paid
- 2009: 4 paid claims, $86,000 paid
- 2010 to 2012: no paid claims
- 2013: 3 paid claims, $5,600 paid
- 2014 to 2015: no paid claims
- 2016: 610 paid claims, $32 million paid
- 2017: 160 paid claims, $5.6 million paid
- 2018 to 2021: no paid claims
- 2022: 130 paid claims, $4.4 million paid
- 2023: 1 paid claim, $7,000 paid
- 2024: 5 paid claims, $70,000 paid
- 2025: 1 paid claim, $4,100 paid
- Hurricane Matthew, 2016: 610 paid claims
- Hurricane Irma, 2017: 150 paid claims
- Hurricane Ian, 2022: 91 paid claims
Paid federal flood insurance claims in Butler Beach each year since 1982.
One event dominates the record in Butler Beach: Hurricane Matthew in 2016 produced 62% of these claims, about 610 of them.
| Flood | Year | Paid claims | Total paid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hurricane Matthew | 2016 | 610 | $31 million |
| Hurricane Irma | 2017 | 150 | $5.5 million |
| Hurricane Ian | 2022 | 91 | $3.9 million |
The median paid claim in Butler Beach was about $26,000, twice the U.S. median of $13,000. Among claims with a water depth above zero, the median claim had about 1 foot of water inside the building, shin-deep.
From 2016 through 2025, 910 claims were paid in Butler Beach, 93% of the total since 1982.
Hurricane storm surge in Butler Beach
A Category 1 hurricane's storm surge could reach 53% of residents in Butler Beach, a Category 3 surge 85% and a Category 5 surge 93%, about 9 in 10. These shares come from the National Hurricane Center's storm surge risk maps and describe Butler Beach as a community, not any one property.
Share of residents of Butler Beach that a storm surge of each category could reach.
Flood zones in Butler Beach
FEMA's map of Butler Beach shows four zones; of the high-risk ones, zone AE holds the most residents, 47%.
| Zone | Share of residents | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| AE | 47% | High risk, with flood heights published |
| VE | 5.9% | High risk on the coast, with waves |
| X (shaded) | 20% | Moderate risk, the 0.2%-a-year or 500-year floodplain |
| X | 27% | Minimal risk, outside the 500-year floodplain |
Flood insurance in Butler Beach
In St. Johns County, 23% of residential buildings carry a federal flood insurance policy, 8 times the U.S. share of 2.9%. St. Johns County has about 22,000 such policies in force.
Standard homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, FEMA notes.
How current is the flood map in Butler Beach?
Nearly every resident of Butler Beach lives on a FEMA flood map panel that took effect in 2018, 8 years before this page's 2026 update. Across the U.S., half of residents live on a panel that took effect in 2013 or earlier.
How Butler Beach compares
Within 12 miles of Butler Beach, the share of residents in FEMA's high-risk zone runs from 1.9% in St. Augustine South, FL to 34% in Vermont Heights, FL, all below the 53% in Butler Beach. Among places of a similar size to Butler Beach, every resident of South Pasadena, FL lives in FEMA's high-risk zone, against 3.4% in West Bradenton, FL.

Questions about flooding in Butler Beach
Is Butler Beach in a flood zone?
Most of Butler Beach is: by BestNeighborhood's estimate, FEMA's high-risk flood zone holds 53% of its residents, about 2,800 people, and the moderate zone another 20%.
Which areas of Butler Beach flood the most?
More residents live in the high-risk zone along the Matanzas River than along any other waterway, about 1,700.
Do I need flood insurance in Butler Beach?
Federal law requires flood insurance on buildings in FEMA's high-risk zone in Butler Beach that carry a mortgage from a federally regulated or insured lender; outside that zone the law does not require it. In St. Johns County, 23% of residential buildings carry a federal flood policy.
How often does it flood in Butler Beach?
Federal flood insurance has paid about 970 claims in Butler Beach since 1982. The most paid claims in Butler Beach came from Hurricane Matthew in 2016. In FEMA's high-risk zone in Butler Beach, a flood has at least a 1 in 4 chance over a 30-year mortgage.
What does flood zone AE mean? And zone X?
Zone AE is high-risk ground where FEMA has published flood heights, home to 47% of residents in Butler Beach. Unshaded zone X is minimal-risk ground outside the 500-year floodplain, home to 27% of residents. Shaded zone X is moderate-risk ground in the 500-year floodplain, with a 0.2% to 1% chance of flooding each year, home to 20% of residents.
How do I find the flood zone for my address in Butler Beach?
The map of Butler Beach above shows the zone street by street; zoom in to an address to read it. For the official zone that lenders and insurers use, FEMA's Flood Map Service Center at msc.fema.gov has the Flood Insurance Rate Map for Butler Beach.
Does this flood map include street and basement flooding from heavy rain?
No, the map of Butler Beach counts rivers, creeks and the coast on FEMA's scale, and rain that floods streets and basements away from a waterway is outside it.
Sources and method
BestNeighborhood's flood model reads FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer at 10-meter detail and counts residents by 2020 Census block. Where FEMA has studied the ground, the value is FEMA's. Elsewhere the value is an estimate of what FEMA's map would show.
Claims and policies come from FEMA's National Flood Insurance Program records. Storm surge shares come from the National Hurricane Center's storm surge risk maps.
Limits
This page is not a flood determination; lenders and insurers use FEMA's Flood Insurance Rate Map.
Rain that floods streets and basements away from rivers, creeks and the coast is not counted.
The high-risk zone means a chance of 1% a year or more, and land right beside a river floods more often than that.
Each value is a mean over a small cell of ground, not a reading for one address.
Claims count only buildings with federal flood insurance.
Sources
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) National Flood Hazard Layer: Flood zones on the map, the share of residents in each zone and the dates of the map panels.
FEMA National Flood Insurance Program claims and policies (OpenFEMA): Paid flood claims, policies in force and their cost. This product uses FEMA's OpenFEMA API but is not endorsed by FEMA; FEMA and the federal government cannot vouch for analyses made from these data.
NOAA National Hurricane Center storm surge risk maps: The share of residents a hurricane's storm surge could reach, by category.
U.S. Census Bureau 2020 Census blocks: Where residents live, so each figure counts people rather than land.
Last updated .
More about Butler Beach
Coming soon: 2027 wildfire risk
A map of wildfire risk for the 2027 fire season is coming to this page for Butler Beach, and to BestNeighborhood for the U.S.

Early access is available now for businesses through paid CrimeGrade reports. Every report includes Disaster Grade Beta, with scores and maps at the report's address for each hazard listed below.
What a business report covers
- Flood
- Wildfire, this season and in a typical year
- Wind
- Tornado wind
- Earthquake
- Hail
- Heat
- Extreme cold