Fire Island renters looking for the least expensive areas to rent should look for the areas towards the red end of the spectrum on the rent cost map. Those who don't mind paying for high-end and luxury apartments should seek out apartments in dark green areas.
On average, the cost of rent in Fire Island is about $1,952 per month. This puts it in the 91st percentile compared to the state average cost of rent, which is $1,514. Households in Fire Island have a median income of $6,924 per month so the average renter in Fire Island is spending roughly 28% of their earnings on housing.
Nationally, and in Fire Island, home values are the data point most closely correlated with the cost of rent. The median price of a home in Fire Island is $417,438 right now, which is lower than nearby cities, meaning that rents in Fire Island also tend to be lower versus these nearby cities.
Higher rent prices are common in the southwestern parts of Fire Island while lower rent rates are often available in eastern areas.
No other site shows detail at this level for free. We are able to keep this site free by receiving a small commission from the referring links below if you book, rent, or request a lead at no cost to you. Please share or cite this page if you aren't able to otherwise support our work.
Map interface © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Map data and content © bestneighborhood