New York / Suffolk County

Shelter Island, NY Flood Map

BestNeighborhood's flood model puts 17% of residents in Shelter Island, about 1 in 6, in a FEMA high-risk flood zone, beside 3.5% for New York and 5.6% for the U.S.

The source of these figures is BestNeighborhood's flood model. It follows FEMA's flood maps wherever FEMA has studied the ground and fills the gaps they leave by learning from the zones FEMA drew on similar land nearby.

Flood map of Shelter Island, NY: the yearly chance of a flood, from white for none to dark blue for 1% a year or more, FEMA's high-risk zone; hatched where not mapped Click for the interactive map
FEMA's high-risk zone
0% a year 1% a year or more
Hatched on the map: Not mapped. The map shows BestNeighborhood's flood model for Shelter Island; zoom in to a street and the color shows its flood zone. Hatching marks ground FEMA's digital flood map does not cover, home to fewer than 1% of residents.

Who should care about this flood map?

This page is for current or potential residents concerned about large-scale flooding risk in Shelter Island. It maps flood zones street by street and shows the 30-year chance of a flood, flood claims paid since 1978 and storm surge.

What this map counts as a flood

This map counts floods from rivers and creeks that leave their banks in Shelter Island. Along the coast it also counts the sea pushed ashore by storms, the flooding FEMA maps in the coastal zones of Shelter Island.

On FEMA's scale, the high-risk zone is the 1%-a-year zone, also called the 100-year floodplain, and about 340 residents of Shelter Island live in it. The moderate zone, where the chance is 0.2% to 1% a year, is home to 34 more.

In Shelter Island, these figures follow FEMA's own flood zones wherever its digital map covers the ground.

Rain that floods streets and basements in Shelter Island away from a waterway is outside this map.

How likely is a flood in Shelter Island?

For residents of Shelter Island in FEMA's high-risk zone, the chance of a flood is 1% or more a year: at least 1 in 4 over a 30-year mortgage. In the moderate zone of Shelter Island, the chance is 0.2% to 1% a year, from about 1 in 17 to 1 in 4 over 30 years.

Flood zoneChance in a yearChance over 30 yearsShelter Island residentsNew York residentsU.S. residents
High risk: Zones AE and VE1% or moreabout 1 in 4 or more17%3.5%5.6%
Moderate risk: Zone X (shaded)0.2% to 1%about 1 in 17 to 1 in 41.7%2.6%4.5%
Minimal risk: Zone Xunder 0.2%under 1 in 1781%84%83%

What flooding looks like in Shelter Island

In Shelter Island, 17% of residents live in FEMA's high-risk flood zone, 3 times the U.S. share of 5.6%. That zone holds about 340 people, and each home in it has at least a 1 in 4 chance of a flood over a 30-year mortgage.

What stands out

  • About 2 in 5 paid flood claims in Shelter Island, 44%, came from buildings outside FEMA's high-risk zone, 1.7 times the U.S. share.
  • The FEMA flood map panel in force for nearly every resident of Shelter Island took effect in 2009, 17 years before this page's 2026 update.

Flood history: what insurance claims show

Since 1978, federal flood insurance has paid 38 claims in Shelter Island, $870,000 in all. These claims count only buildings insured by the National Flood Insurance Program, so uninsured flood damage in Shelter Island is not in them.

  • 1978: 3 paid claims, $8,300 paid
  • 1979 to 1981: no paid claims
  • 1982: 1 paid claim, $720 paid
  • 1983: no paid claims
  • 1984: 4 paid claims, $9,400 paid
  • 1985 to 1988: no paid claims
  • 1989: 1 paid claim, $790 paid
  • 1990: no paid claims
  • 1991: 5 paid claims, $110,000 paid
  • 1992: 5 paid claims, $140,000 paid
  • 1993 to 2004: no paid claims
  • 2005: 1 paid claim, $4,200 paid
  • 2006: no paid claims
  • 2007: 1 paid claim, $3,200 paid
  • 2008: 1 paid claim, $3,100 paid
  • 2009: no paid claims
  • 2010: 2 paid claims, $14,000 paid
  • 2011: no paid claims
  • 2012: 13 paid claims, $570,000 paid
  • 2013 to 2016: no paid claims
  • 2017: 1 paid claim, $3,500 paid
  • 2018 to 2025: no paid claims
  • The "Halloween" Storm, 1991: 5 paid claims
  • December Nor'easter, 1992: 5 paid claims
  • Hurricane Sandy, 2012: 13 paid claims

Paid federal flood insurance claims in Shelter Island each year since 1978.

In Shelter Island, Hurricane Sandy in 2012 caused the most, 13 claims or 34% of the total, followed by the December Nor'easter in 1992 and the "Halloween" Storm in 1991.

FloodYearPaid claimsTotal paid
Hurricane Sandy201213$570,000
December Nor'easter19925$140,000
The "Halloween" Storm19915$110,000
Flooding in 198419844$9,400
Flooding in 197819783$8,300

The median paid claim in Shelter Island was about $7,000, about half the U.S. median of $13,000.

From 2016 through 2025, 1 claim was paid in Shelter Island, 2.6% of the total since 1978.

Hurricane storm surge in Shelter Island

Storm surge from a Category 5 hurricane could reach 19% of residents in Shelter Island, about 1 in 5, against 2.4% for a Category 1 and 8.2% for a Category 3. These shares come from the National Hurricane Center's storm surge risk maps and describe Shelter Island as a community, not any one property.

  1. Category 1 hurricane: 2.4%
  2. Category 2 hurricane: 5%
  3. Category 3 hurricane: 8.2%
  4. Category 4 hurricane: 19%
  5. Category 5 hurricane: 19%

Share of residents of Shelter Island that a storm surge of each category could reach.

Flood zones in Shelter Island

FEMA's map of Shelter Island shows four zones; of the high-risk ones, zone AE holds the most residents, 12%.

ZoneShare of residentsWhat it means
AE12%High risk, with flood heights published
VE5.2%High risk on the coast, with waves
X (shaded)1.7%Moderate risk, the 0.2%-a-year or 500-year floodplain
X81%Minimal risk, outside the 500-year floodplain

Flood insurance in Shelter Island

In Suffolk County, 5.4% of residential buildings carry a federal flood insurance policy, 1.9 times the U.S. share of 2.9%. Suffolk County has about 26,000 such policies in force.

Standard homeowners insurance does not cover flood damage, FEMA notes.

How current is the flood map in Shelter Island?

Nearly every resident of Shelter Island lives on a FEMA flood map panel that took effect in 2009, 17 years before this page's 2026 update. Across the U.S., half of residents live on a panel that took effect in 2013 or earlier.

How Shelter Island compares

Within 6 miles of Shelter Island, the share of residents in FEMA's high-risk zone runs from 3.9% in Shelter Island Heights, NY to 20% in East Marion, NY, with Shelter Island at 17%. Among places of a similar size to Shelter Island, Amagansett, NY has the highest share, 26%, and Clintondale, NY the lowest, 2%.

Flood map of the lower 48 states
The flood map across the lower 48 states, in the same colors as the map of Shelter Island above.

Questions about flooding in Shelter Island

Is Shelter Island in a flood zone?

Parts of Shelter Island are: by BestNeighborhood's estimate, FEMA's high-risk flood zone holds 17% of its residents, about 340 people, and the moderate zone another 1.7%.

Do I need flood insurance in Shelter Island?

Federal law requires flood insurance on buildings in FEMA's high-risk zone in Shelter Island that carry a mortgage from a federally regulated or insured lender; outside that zone the law does not require it. In Suffolk County, 5.4% of residential buildings carry a federal flood policy.

How often does it flood in Shelter Island?

Federal flood insurance has paid 38 claims in Shelter Island since 1978. The most paid claims in Shelter Island came from Hurricane Sandy in 2012. In FEMA's high-risk zone in Shelter Island, a flood has at least a 1 in 4 chance over a 30-year mortgage.

What does flood zone AE mean? And zone X?

Zone AE is high-risk ground where FEMA has published flood heights, home to 12% of residents in Shelter Island. Unshaded zone X is minimal-risk ground outside the 500-year floodplain, home to 81% of residents. Shaded zone X is moderate-risk ground in the 500-year floodplain, with a 0.2% to 1% chance of flooding each year, home to 1.7% of residents.

How do I find the flood zone for my address in Shelter Island?

The map of Shelter Island above shows the zone street by street; zoom in to an address to read it. For the official zone that lenders and insurers use, FEMA's Flood Map Service Center at msc.fema.gov has the Flood Insurance Rate Map for Shelter Island.

Does this flood map include street and basement flooding from heavy rain?

No, the map of Shelter Island counts rivers, creeks and the coast on FEMA's scale, and rain that floods streets and basements away from a waterway is outside it.

Sources and method

BestNeighborhood's flood model reads FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer at 10-meter detail and counts residents by 2020 Census block. Where FEMA has studied the ground, the value is FEMA's. Elsewhere the value is an estimate of what FEMA's map would show.

Claims and policies come from FEMA's National Flood Insurance Program records. Storm surge shares come from the National Hurricane Center's storm surge risk maps.

Limits
This page is not a flood determination; lenders and insurers use FEMA's Flood Insurance Rate Map.
Rain that floods streets and basements away from rivers, creeks and the coast is not counted.
The high-risk zone means a chance of 1% a year or more, and land right beside a river floods more often than that.
Each value is a mean over a small cell of ground, not a reading for one address.
Claims count only buildings with federal flood insurance.

Sources
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) National Flood Hazard Layer: Flood zones on the map, the share of residents in each zone and the dates of the map panels.
FEMA National Flood Insurance Program claims and policies (OpenFEMA): Paid flood claims, policies in force and their cost. This product uses FEMA's OpenFEMA API but is not endorsed by FEMA; FEMA and the federal government cannot vouch for analyses made from these data.
NOAA National Hurricane Center storm surge risk maps: The share of residents a hurricane's storm surge could reach, by category.
U.S. Census Bureau 2020 Census blocks: Where residents live, so each figure counts people rather than land.

How the flood map is made, and what it leaves out

Last updated .

More about Shelter Island

Coming soon: 2027 wildfire risk

A wildfire risk map for the 2027 fire season is coming soon: for Shelter Island on this page, and for the U.S. on BestNeighborhood.

Wildfire risk map of the lower 48 states
The lower 48 states

Early access is available now for businesses through paid CrimeGrade reports. Every report includes Disaster Grade Beta, with scores and maps at the report's address for each hazard listed below.

What a business report covers

  • Flood
  • Wildfire, this season and in a typical year
  • Wind
  • Tornado wind
  • Earthquake
  • Hail
  • Heat
  • Extreme cold

CrimeGrade business reports · See an example report