Expensive
Affordable
Affordable
Colorblind friendly
off
These days, finding an affordable place to live in the Shelter Island Heights area can be challenging. Home prices in Shelter Island Heights are now at a median cost of $1,143,205, higher than the New York average of $610,895.
The average cost of rent is $2,255/mo in Shelter Island Heights, primarily driven by the current value of real estate in the Shelter Island Heights area. In Shelter Island Heights, 0.00% of households rent, and 67.16% of homeowners own their homes outright.
Housing affordability isn’t just about home prices, though. The average household income in Shelter Island Heights is $11,164 per month. Households that rent pay about 20.20% of their income on rent here. Shelter Island Heights’s most expensive areas are in the southern regions, while the cheapest areas are in the central parts of the city.
Source: BestNeighborhood calculations from the U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey (ACS) 2020-2024 5-year estimates.
Nearby Cities
- Shelter Island, NY: equally priced homes
- Dering Harbor, NY: equally priced homes
- Greenport West, NY: less expensive homes
- Greenport, NY: less expensive homes
- Southold, NY: less expensive homes
- East Marion, NY: less expensive homes
- North Haven, NY: higher priced homes
- Noyack, NY: equally priced homes
- Peconic, NY: equally priced homes
- Orient, NY: less expensive homes
Cities with Similar Populations
- Williford, AR: less expensive homes
- Barbourmeade, KY: less expensive homes
- Beaver Meadows, PA: less expensive homes
- Myton, UT: less expensive homes
- Morrisville, MO: less expensive homes
- Nakina, NC: less expensive homes
- Nauvoo, IL: less expensive homes
- Nazlini, AZ: less expensive homes
- Neches, TX: less expensive homes
- Nettie, WV: less expensive homes
No other site shows detail at this level for free. We are able to keep this site free by receiving a small commission from the referring links below if you book, rent, or request a lead at no cost to you. Please share or cite this page if you aren’t able to otherwise support our work.
Map interface © Mapbox © OpenStreetMap Map data and content © bestneighborhood